The assistant problem: what it costs over 20 years, and the 10-second correction

According to the 2025 Women in the Workplace report produced by McKinsey and LeanIn, women in leadership roles are roughly double as likely as men to be assumed to hold a more junior position. If you have been asked to take the minutes, grab the coffee or confirm the conference room in Indianapolis while your title includes "vice president," you are part of that data.

What makes the figure hit hard is not simply that it occurs. Plenty of women in Central Indiana already have a story to tell. It is that the study measured the pattern among leaders, women who had already passed every hurdle their organization set. The error does not go away as you climb. It comes along with you. A director gets mistaken for the coordinator. A C-suite executive finds a stranger holding out a coat for them to take. The cue the room is picking up is not your title. It is you.

Source of the figure

Women in the Workplace is a yearly study of US corporate employers, run by McKinsey and LeanIn since 2015, that surveys both companies and their staff. Leaders in the latest edition were surveyed about small, daily encounters at their jobs, and being mistaken for someone lower-ranking turns up among them, with women experiencing it at twice the frequency reported by men. It relies on self-reporting, so it captures what people noticed and recalled, not every single instance. Nor does the data reveal who made that assumption, or what led them there. What it does show is that this is a recurring pattern, common enough to appear in a national survey, not something that happens only to you.

Form it takes

Picture a quarterly review at a company near the Monument Circle downtown. You are the senior vice president in Carmel responsible for the metrics displayed on the screen. Arriving early to a Westfield board meeting, a new member scans the room and inquires whether the SVP will be along shortly. You say, politely, that she is already sitting there. He is briefly embarrassed, then recovers, and for the rest of the meeting he is oddly cautious around you, which carries a cost of its own. That slip was made without any hostility at all. It reflected the room's reflexive presumption, which was that the person in charge had to be somebody else entirely.

What this means for your work

Across Central Indiana, this is commonly labeled the support-role dilemma. Every such incident takes roughly ten seconds and a brief loss of poise. The total cost is larger. As an illustration, a single incident per month over a two-decade career in Central Indiana would total about 240 instances where a stranger's first impression of you needed correcting before real business could begin. Those first impressions are where credibility gets priced, and that is the real expense. The problem is not that your appearance suggests a lower rank. It is that the room's idea of "senior" was formed by picturing who used to hold the job.

Reply approach

Correct it in ten seconds, every time, without heat and without moving on to other topics. If you can, address it before anyone misreads the situation by saying, "I'm the SVP for the Indianapolis region. You'll be presenting to me today." When you can't get ahead of it, fix it in the same even tone you'd use to correct a wrong date: "I'm actually the SVP. Shall we begin?" Keep it free of humor, apology, or hesitation. You are updating a faulty data point, and the quickest update wins.

Across your years in Fishers and Noblesville, which fix have you had to make most often, and how long did it take before you stopped apologizing as you made it?

Sources: