Why decisiveness reads as "difficult" on you, and the three moves that change the read
Across two decades, the advice here has stayed consistent. When a resolute choice gets labeled "difficult" as you announce it, the temptation is to cushion how you say it. Smile more. Open with "I might be wrong, but." Thank colleagues for their patience. Surround the hard call with enough warmth that no one registers you made one. Coaches describe this as managing perception, and the people giving it generally mean well.
Softening does not take away the penalty. Doing so suggests your authority requires an apology, and it erodes the clarity that gave the decision its force to begin with.
First The penalty sticks to the individual, so altering your manner won't alter what it costs you.
Research on the likability penalty has repeatedly found that the same request is heard as assertive from a man and as demanding from a woman. The word "same" is what matters. The language was identical, and the reaction differed only because of who spoke it. Adjusting your delivery addresses a factor the research suggests is irrelevant, and leaves untouched the one that counts.
Second Asking nicely has already been attempted on a broad scale.
Kray, Kennedy and Lee of the Berkeley Haas School of Business found in 2023 that 54% of women negotiated their most recent job offer, compared with 44% of men, and the women still earned less. Women are not holding back their requests. They are asking, often with great care, and still paying for it. Were courtesy the solution, that disparity would have been resolved a long time ago.
Third Cushioning a decision charges you again on the one that follows.
Each "I might be wrong" remains on the record. At the next tough call, the group recalls your hedging and reads the new choice in light of that recollection. A man who made the same call without the hedge is described as "decisive." You are described as "unsure." You have paid the penalty twice: once for being a woman, and again for the cushion you added to avoid being seen as one.
Where the older advice still holds true
Warmth is a real asset, and many of the women leading Indianapolis organizations have it in abundance. The error lies in viewing warmth as a markdown on authority rather than a strength that stands on its own. Be kind. Be clear. Do not exchange one for the other.
Better alternative
Tie the decision to a benchmark. "Our policy is that nothing ships without the security review, and this one hasn't received it." At that point, the group is no longer debating you. They are debating the policy, and policies seldom get described as difficult.
Start by getting it on paper. A choice delivered in a written memo, supported by stated reasoning, comes across as procedure. That same choice spoken aloud in the room comes across as temperament. Circulate the memo first, then convene the meeting to talk it through, letting the document convey the resolve.
Acknowledge the cost before someone else raises it. "The vendor will not be happy about this, but I'm proceeding because of our audit exposure." By naming the "difficult" yourself and linking it to a rationale, you leave no room for it to be turned against you. Rationale is what people tend to presume assertive men already possess. Give yours out loud.
Which decision in Indianapolis, Carmel, or anywhere across Central Indiana are you softening right now that you would state plainly if you were confident the room would read it as leadership?