Inflation, your market rate, and the quiet message your company just sent

Most people in Indianapolis who get a 3% raise say thank you and move on. Before you do, though, work through three numbers, because when inflation is also 3%, that raise adds up to nothing in real terms, however warmly the email is written.

Still, that alone does not turn it into an insult. It's simply the standard figure. What matters is whether it reflects what your work is worth, and you can only find that out by measuring it against something other than your salary from last year.

The inflation check

Subtract the current year's inflation figure from the increase you were given. If what's left is close to zero, your pay hasn't really moved. Your employer left your salary unchanged in Indianapolis and called it recognition. If the result is negative, you've effectively taken a cut and been asked to say thanks for it.

The compensation audit

Your market rate is what it would cost to replace you, not last year's pay plus a bit more. Salary ranges now show up on more job listings each year, so pull three postings for your title and level, here in Indy or across Central Indiana, and look at the midpoint. A short look at local listings in Carmel or Fishers will reveal more than a year of speculation. If you're below that midpoint, a 3% raise isn't closing the distance. The market kept moving too, so the gap is probably wider than it was at the start of the year.

The squeezed-pay review

Companies generally spend more to bring in a new hire than to hold onto someone already on staff. If a newer colleague at your level was brought in above you, each 3% raise carries that difference forward. Imagine the shortfall amounts to $10,000. Across ten years of matching 3% increases, that one gap builds to roughly $115,000 in pay you never received, before the bonus and retirement match calculated on top of it.

What the number tells you

A 3% raise typically sends one of three messages: "You're fine where you are," "Nobody argued for you," or "Nobody asked." Only the last one is good news, because it's the one you can change in a single conversation.

Picture a director in Carmel, Indiana, earning $150,000 who gets the usual 3% bump. Only eight months before, the newcomer brought onto her team in Fishers was paid $162,000 from the start. Today the gap is $12,000. After both receive 3%, it becomes $12,360, since 3% of his higher salary is more than 3% of hers. Nobody in that chain did anything wrong, yet she is still falling further behind.

Preparation checklist before you say thank you

Request the salary range attached to your position. "I'd like to understand where I sit in the salary range for my level." Most managers will tell you, and the ones who won't have told you something useful as well.

Walk in with the three figures in hand, rather than relying only on how you feel. "The midpoint for my role is X. I'm at Y. What would it take to close that gap this year?" You're asking a question about arithmetic, which is much harder to brush off than a complaint about fairness.

If the response is "budget," ask for a date and a figure, and ask for both in writing. A manager who is serious about retention will agree to both. Someone who is not will agree to neither, and that refusal tells you something as well.

What did your last raise communicate to you?

Sources: