Calibration sessions, talent reviews, and what your advocate needs in her hands before she walks in

Conventional wisdom on talent reviews holds that your performance should speak for itself in Indianapolis and beyond. Maintain strong metrics, keep your manager informed along the way, and trust that the process will work in your favor. Well-run organizations hold calibration sessions for exactly this reason, so that promotions aren't settled by whoever projects the most volume. Expecting that much is reasonable, since the process was designed with good intentions behind it.

Yet the work doesn't really speak for itself. Someone speaks on its behalf, in a room you will never set foot in, for roughly ninety seconds, and what she says hinges almost entirely on what you placed in her hands before she went in.

1. Discussions in the room move at speed, and details fade fast.

A single afternoon of calibration can reach dozens of people across Indianapolis and its suburbs. Each name receives a minute or two. Under mild pressure, your advocate reaches into her memory for what she can remember, while four colleagues look over a nine-box grid. Should she need to reconstruct your twelve months from recall alone, the latest project and any issue that was escalated are what she is likely to bring up. With a half-page sitting in front of her, she has something concrete to read aloud. The Women in the Workplace 2025 report from McKinsey and LeanIn found that women in leadership roles are two times more likely than their peers to be taken for someone junior. Hurried rooms leave people with an even thinner and more hazy sense of who you are.

2. This room was never built with the goal of advocating for you.

The same study finds that only 54% of companies in Central Indiana place women's advancement near the top of their agenda. The group will work through its agenda and then keep moving. Protecting the people on one's own team is a normal part of the job, and nobody in the room is at fault for doing it. What it means is that if your advocate arrives unprepared, the likely result is "solid, keep developing," a verdict that could be attached to nearly anyone and that advances no one.

3. Concerns get raised, yet there is no one on hand to respond to them.

During calibration, someone may say, "I'm not confident she's ready for the scope." If your advocate has a reply ready, the discussion moves forward. When no one speaks up, the concern remains unchallenged, is recorded as an area for growth, and shows up in your review as if it had already been resolved. The sentence that shapes your career most could be one you never get to hear, whether it gets rebutted or not, spoken by someone who was never equipped to push back.

Where the old advice still holds up in Central Indiana

Your efforts still carry weight. A one-page brief cannot compensate for a weak year, and an advocate who reads strong claims off a page that the room doesn't recognize loses credibility for both of you. The process is also genuinely preferable to having none. Calibration is meant to expose favoritism, and every so often it actually succeeds at that.

A stronger option

Roughly one month ahead of the review, hand your manager a half-page summary instead of a slide deck. List three results with numbers. Describe two contributions that went past what your role required. State the role you want next. Then add one line answering the objection you expect: "If scope comes up, the vendor consolidation covered three regions and eleven stakeholders." Finally, ask the question that matters most: "When my name comes up, what are you planning to say?" Most managers haven't considered it. You will have prompted them to, in writing, which is the one thing that holds up in a fast room.

Who is advocating for you in this cycle, and what materials do they actually have on hand?

Sources: