What each demands, how each pays, and who thrives in each

Tuesday has arrived for the first time in twenty-six years with no calendar to answer to, and three emails are waiting on your screen in Indianapolis. A former CEO, based in Carmel, is offering you a fractional chief operating officer role spanning two days each week. A board recruiter, reaching out from Zionsville, explains that your name surfaced during a discussion about open seats. A former vendor in Greenwood proposes paying you to find out what their customers really think of them. You are 56. The decision in front of you has moved beyond selecting one offer from the pile. The question is which way of working you hope to shape.

What each route expects from you in return

Part-time executive roles lean on the practical know-how you have built up over the years. You take charge of a real operation on a part-time basis for a company in Fishers that cannot yet afford a full-time executive. The pay looks like a salary with the benefits stripped away, more than you might expect and less than you once earned. This path fits those who crave getting things done and have little patience for corporate maneuvering. Watch for the slow creep where a two-day commitment swells to four days, yet your job title never admits you've become a full-time contributor.

Sitting on a board demands your sound judgment and your discipline to hold back. You do a lot of reading, weigh in only occasionally, and stand accountable for choices you never made yourself. Public company boards offer a retainer and frequently include equity as well. Private and nonprofit boards frequently pay less or nothing, and that first seat is usually one of those. This suits people who can watch an executive make mistakes without seizing control of the situation. The risk is that the search can stretch for years.

Consulting work leans on who you know and how far your contacts reach. Every quarter you must market yourself before any paid work begins. Money comes in project by project, so earnings swing unevenly, and your strongest jobs usually trace back to people in Westfield or Lawrence who already know what you can do. It suits people who enjoy the pitch. The hazard is that you end up doing all the selling yourself, and that sales work never lets up long enough for you to take a break.

The turning point

Looking closer, you realize these three emails do not open three separate paths forward. Instead they represent three sources of income, and the leaders who do well after reaching the top seldom rely on only one. In the first year, a fractional position can keep the lights on. Consulting builds the reputation that gets the board recruiter calling you back, even from Avon or Plainfield. When a board seat finally lands, it turns the next fractional offer into one that comes to you rather than one you chase. The question is less which to choose and more which to start with, and the sensible answer is whichever one someone will pay for this month.

Why this reaches past your own circumstances

In 2025, women started 44% of new businesses, a rise from 29% in 2019, figures Forbes reported and Black Enterprise later passed along. Many of those ventures are second acts, built by women who discovered the corporate ladder ended two rungs early. Executive judgment that is bought by the day is a valuable asset in its own right, not a second-best option. It is a real market, and Central Indiana has plenty of it, from the pharmaceutical and manufacturing employers that anchor the region to the growing healthcare and construction sectors around Carmel, Fishers and Greenwood.

Three lessons worth holding onto

1. Answer the fractional email first. Request a scope in writing along with a daily rate, and be clear: "Two days a week means exactly two days. What will we do if it grows to three?" How they respond will show you what kind of client they are going to be.

2. Plan the board search on a two-year timeline, pacing each phase deliberately. Accept the first seat that gives you real learning and a story worth telling, even if no one pays you for it. Boards usually choose candidates who have already sat on one before. Indy's chamber and women's networks, including OneZone Women's Network in Carmel and the Central Indiana Women's Business Center, are good places to meet the people who make those introductions.

3. Accept the vendor's offer, and get the invoice out before you put together any presentation. Whatever rate you charge your first consulting client becomes the benchmark everyone after them expects you to match. Free resources like SCORE Indianapolis and the Indiana Small Business Development Center can help you get the numbers right before you quote your first day rate.

Three inboxes, three paths, all in a single Tuesday in Carmel. The calendar sits blank, and for the first time in a long while, you get to decide what goes on it.

Sources: