Inside the "Great Breakup," and what it means for the women who stay

Back in 2022, the year Lean In and McKinsey gave the "Great Breakup" its name, two women directors were exiting their employers for every single one who earned a promotion. These weren't women leaving paid work altogether. They were leaving the building, taking their badge and their hard-won institutional knowledge with them, while the company moved just one woman up for each two who headed out the door.

Why the number hurts

Director is supposed to be the rung where the worst is behind you. You got through the lean early years, the juggling of parental leave, the manager who assumed you were the assistant. You now hold a title that comes with a budget. Yet this is exactly the level where women were departing at double the pace of their advancement. The leak wasn't near the bottom of the pipeline. It sprang up at the stage where the company had already invested heavily to fill that seat.

Where the number comes from, and what it can't say

The statistic traces back to the 2022 edition of Women in the Workplace, the yearly study put out by Lean In and McKinsey, and it drew wide coverage, including from Katie Couric Media. Its boundaries deserve attention. This figure comes from one year of data supplied voluntarily by firms, and that pool skews toward big American employers. "Leaving" refers to departing that particular company, not walking away from corporate careers. Certain directors moved to a comparable post elsewhere, a step forward for them and a setback only for the employer that lost them. The 2025 edition indicates the underlying pattern has yet to ease. Among men elevated to manager, 93 out of every 100 women are elevated too, yet that number slides to 74 once the women are women of color. Eighty percent of women say they hope to be promoted, compared with 86% of men, and that difference fades once support is distributed equally. The ambition is present. Support is what varies.

Imagine what it feels like from within Indy's boardrooms.

Imagine you are a director in one of Indianapolis's large employers, whether in healthcare, manufacturing, or finance. Two of the four women at your level have gone in the last eighteen months. One took a bigger title at a competitor. Another launched her own venture. During the Indianapolis leadership offsite, the chief people officer presents retention data on a single slide and never once uses the names of the women who left. You realize you are now the most senior woman in the room, and that no one has asked what it would take to keep you there.

Consider what this signals to the women who stay in Central Indiana.

Staying put after a wave of departures isn't automatically the safe move. You are in a negotiation you may not have realized you had entered. Your employer has just watched talent walk out the door, and it is now aware that you could be the next to go. Your position carries bargaining power, but that power erodes over time. A year on, the exits will be ancient history, and your continued presence will simply be counted as loyalty, the least expensive thing an employer can get.

Staying also tends to push more work onto your plate. With fewer senior women around, the requests multiply: another panel, another mentoring session, another "could you sit in on this." None of that counts toward a promotion, yet all of it now lands on you.

What steps should be taken in response to it?

Open the retention discussion your company should have started by now, and begin it this month instead of waiting until next quarter. You might say something along these lines: "Two of my colleagues walked away this year. I want to stay. What does my next role look like, and what's the timeline?" An employer that wants to keep you will answer with a specific role and a date. One that doesn't will offer praise. Both responses tell you something useful, but only the first one spares you another year of waiting.

If your firm in Fishers or Westfield lost women directors this year, has anyone reached out to ask you to remain?

Sources: